Discussing Money With Family – Are You A Thermostat Or A Thermometer?

Money remains a sensitive and complex topic yet discussing it across generations can add another layer of connection. The dynamics of generational conversations about money are akin to the workings of a thermostat and a thermometer – two devices that measure and regulate temperature but in fundamentally different ways. Understanding these approaches can foster healthier discussions, bridge generational gaps, and facilitate better financial decisions.

The Thermometer Approach

The thermometer is a reactive device; it merely reflects the current state of the environment. Similarly, the thermometer approach to discussing money involves reacting to immediate financial circumstances without necessarily considering long-term implications or strategies. External influences include economic conditions, life transitions, immediate wants or needs. Research has found the behavioral finance biases of anchoring, loss aversion, mental accounting and herding can be seen as our Internal “head space” thermometer.

In the context of generational conversations about money, the thermometer approach might involve addressing immediate financial challenges without delving into the root causes, financial scripts considering unintended consequences.  For example, discussions may revolve around managing debt, covering monthly bills, or dealing with unexpected expenses. While these conversations are necessary, the thermometer approach often lacks the depth required for comprehensive fiscal decision making.

The Thermostat Approach

In contrast, the thermostat is a proactive device that regulates the environment to maintain a desired temperature based on external and internal considerations. Applying the thermostat approach to money conversations involves taking a proactive stance, focusing on long-term financial goals, mitigating and managing various aspects of risk and strategically adjusting and making course corrections. This method necessitates awareness of the current financial situation, what is your desired comfort level, and how do you keep it sustainable?

When dealing with generational discussions about money using the thermostat approach, the emphasis is on financial literacy, creating healthy identities around money, what are family values around money and what tools can be used for building true wealth. Conversations may revolve around family messages about money and how it impacts decision making, daily decisions, saving for the future, investing wisely, and understanding the value of assets. This method encourages a holistic understanding of money, empowering individuals to navigate the complexities of financial decisions throughout their lives.

Generational Perspectives

Different generations may naturally gravitate towards one approach over the other, reflecting their unique experiences and attitudes towards money. For instance, older generations, such as Baby Boomers, may lean towards the thermostat approach, having weathered economic fluctuations and crises of the past and now want the consistency of sustainable cash flow throughout their fall and winter season of life.

On the other hand, younger generations, such as Millennials and Gen Z, may embrace the thermometer approach.  They may be more comfortable with changes in market conditions and flexible with lifestyle choices. With access to a wealth of information and technology, these generations have the ability to quickly pivot.

Bridging the Gap

Effectively navigating generational conversations about money requires finding a balance between the thermostat and thermometer approaches. The goal is to combine the wisdom of past experiences with the forward-thinking mindset needed to adapt to an ever-changing financial landscape.

One way to bridge this gap is through intergenerational financial transparency. Older generations can share practical insights and lessons learned from their experiences, providing a valuable historical perspective. Younger generations, in turn, can contribute innovative ideas, technological insights, and a fresh perspective on navigating the modern financial world.

Communication is Key

Regardless of the chosen approach, effective communication is essential for successful generational money conversations. It’s important to create a safe and open space where family members can share their financial memories, mindsets, goals, concerns, and aspirations without judgment.

Using metaphors like the thermostat and thermometer can help facilitate understanding between generations. Acknowledging and appreciating the strengths of both approaches can lead to more productive discussions, fostering a collaborative environment where each generation contributes to the family’s overall financial well-being.

Generational conversations about money are inherently complex, reflecting the diverse experiences and perspectives within a family. By understanding and embracing both the thermostat and thermometer approaches, families can create a harmonious and inclusive environment. Striking a balance between reactive and proactive financial discussions will pave the way for a more resilient and adaptable family financial culture, capable of withstanding the challenges of life transitions and economic climate.

Share this episode